When a federal judge ruled last month in favour of Woodfibre LNG香蕉视频直播檚 floating work camp to keep housing workers near Squamish, it seemed at first glance the legal challenge had failed.
The judicial review case asked the court to overturn the federal government香蕉视频直播檚 approval of the 香蕉视频直播渇loatel香蕉视频直播� 香蕉视频直播� a former Estonian cruise liner converted into a massive worker accommodation vessel, stationed seven kilometres from the B.C. community on Howe Sound.
香蕉视频直播淚 guess I was hoping that it would be a way for us to stop Woodfibre LNG,香蕉视频直播� S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh Elder Tiaoutenaat (Jackie Williams) reflected, as she sat shaded from the sun at St香蕉视频直播櫭�7mes (Stawamus), one of the nation香蕉视频直播檚 six reserves.
Tiaoutenaat was one of the applicants behind the judicial review case, alongside a 17-year-old S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh Youth (whom IndigiNews is not identifying as she is a minor) and local environmental group My Sea to Sky.
In the end, Justice S茅bastien Grammond upheld the floatel香蕉视频直播檚 authorization.
But according to the lawsuit香蕉视频直播檚 applicants, the case became about something bigger.
And after the province launched public consultations on adding a second floating workforce housing vessel on July 8, the stakes for those concerned about gender-based violence are even higher.
State has duty 香蕉视频直播榯o prevent gender-based violence
Although the judge didn香蕉视频直播檛 strike down the government香蕉视频直播檚 approval of the floatel, he acknowledged in a June 20 ruling that the presence of a largely male construction workforce could potentially increase the risk of gender-based violence in nearby communities.
He also accepted that this violence risk 香蕉视频直播� although 香蕉视频直播渙pen to debate香蕉视频直播� 香蕉视频直播� touches on core guarantees to safety, equality, and protection from discrimination in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
香蕉视频直播淚 am prepared to assume, without deciding, that the presence of a largely male construction workforce gives rise to a heightened risk of gender-based violence in neighbouring communities,香蕉视频直播� Grammond wrote, noting gender-based violence impacts values enshrined in the Charter.
香蕉视频直播淭hese values translate into a duty of the state to take reasonable measures to prevent gender-based violence. There is a sufficient nexus between greenlighting the floatel proposal and a heightened risk of gender-based violence.香蕉视频直播�
Sue Brown, the lawyer representing Tiaoutenaat and the S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh Youth through the advocacy group Justice for Girls, said this framing creates a legal pathway for future cases, even if the court didn香蕉视频直播檛 rule definitively on those rights here.
香蕉视频直播淲e got a really, really strong statement from the court on the Charter and how it ought to apply in the context of decisions related to oil and gas projects,香蕉视频直播� she said.
Brown says the court香蕉视频直播檚 decision creates a precedent 香蕉视频直播� affirming authorities have a 香蕉视频直播渄ue diligence obligation香蕉视频直播� to consider and prevent gender-based violence when they review proposed extractive industry projects.
香蕉视频直播淭he state now has an obligation to fulfill that duty,香蕉视频直播� Brown said.
She added that this is the first time she香蕉视频直播檚 seen a 香蕉视频直播淐anadian香蕉视频直播� court articulate that obligation so clearly 香蕉视频直播� a step she described as 香蕉视频直播渕assive.香蕉视频直播�
A divisive oil and gas project
The Eagle Mountain-Woodfibre Gas Pipeline 香蕉视频直播� operated by FortisBC to supply the liquefied natural gas (LNG) plant 香蕉视频直播� spans roughly 47 kilometres, starting near the Coquitlam watershed and ending at the Woodfibre LNG terminal on the shores of Howe Sound.
A short boat ride from Squamish, the plant is visible from Sp香蕉视频直播檃kw香蕉视频直播檜s (Feather Park), the town香蕉视频直播檚 new beachfront park, and the highway 香蕉视频直播� particularly at night when intense floodlights cast a glow across the inlet, making it resemble a small industrial city.
A nine kilometre tunnel will pass beneath the Squamish Estuary and connect to FortisBC香蕉视频直播檚 existing infrastructure, carrying fracked gas extracted in northeastern B.C. and Alberta through a network of pipelines across the province.
When the gas reaches the Woodfibre plant, it香蕉视频直播檒l be cooled into liquid using hydro-powered electric compressors and loaded onto tankers, which will voyage past 香蕉视频直播淰ancouver香蕉视频直播� and 香蕉视频直播淰ictoria香蕉视频直播� before heading to markets in Asia.
Companies including British-owned BP and Chinese-owned Guangzhou Gas are already contracted to receive exports.
The province promotes LNG as part of a cleaner energy future.
But some S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh community members remain troubled about the long-term impacts of fracked gas and increased industrialization in their homelands and beyond.
Recent federal moves in response to the trade war 香蕉视频直播� such as the recently enacted One Canadian Economy Act (Bill香蕉视频直播疌香蕉视频直播�5), along with 香蕉视频直播淏.C.香蕉视频直播檚香蕉视频直播� new provincial legislation (Bills香蕉视频直播�14 and 15) 香蕉视频直播� would fast-track similar industrial projects.
The bills position major extractive projects such as oil and gas as matters of national and economic security.
Back in 2015, S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh Nation香蕉视频直播檚 elected government signed onto the Woodfibre and its associated pipeline projects, saying it 香蕉视频直播渃onducted the first legally-binding Indigenous-led environmental assessments in Canada,香蕉视频直播� through 香蕉视频直播渆xtensive community engagement.香蕉视频直播�
But as Tiaoutenaat alleged, 香蕉视频直播淭hey called a community meeting at the 13th hour,香蕉视频直播� arguing the meeting had low turnout with an estimated 30 people. She said a majority of participants opposed the proposed deals, requesting instead a community referendum.
But the nation went ahead with the project, saying that it 香蕉视频直播渧oiced the need for the nation香蕉视频直播檚 culture, values and priorities to be reflected when assessing such large projects,香蕉视频直播� S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh 脷xwumixw states on its website.
香蕉视频直播淏etween 2013 and 2015 香蕉视频直播� extensive community engagement and technical review led to the nation ultimately approving both projects with conditions to ensure environmental, cultural, archaeological, and social priorities were addressed with nation oversight.香蕉视频直播�
Meanwhile, many members of the newly elected council that followed, in 2017, ran under a campaign that opposed Woodfibre.
香蕉视频直播淚 think that the last council was guided by a set of principles that they tried to bring forward and I think that the community didn香蕉视频直播檛 agree with those principles,香蕉视频直播� elected councillor Khelsilem told CBC at the time.
香蕉视频直播淚 think the community spoke loudly and clearly that they do not support the development of Woodfibre LNG in our territory and they香蕉视频直播檝e elected people who are ready to stand up for our environment.香蕉视频直播�
IndigiNews requested an interview with S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh leadership but did not hear back before publication time.
Community members like Tiaoutenaat still remember the harm caused by the old Britannia Mines (closed in 1974), the Woodfibre Pulp Mill (closed in 2006), and the FMC Canada/Canadian-Oxy mercury cell chlor-alkali plant (closed in 1991). With so much industry located on the waters of 脕tl香蕉视频直播欋傅a7tsem, there have been decades of pollution which drove marine life away, she reflected.
香蕉视频直播淲e香蕉视频直播檙e only just seeing it come back to life,香蕉视频直播� said Tiaoutenaat, her voice breaking.
Woodfibre LNG香蕉视频直播檚 floatel has been moored and occupied at the Woodfibre LNG site on Howe Sound since June 21 of last year 香蕉视频直播� despite lacking a municipal permit from the District of Squamish.
Days after the municipal council voted to reject its one-year temporary use permit, Woodfibre moved the floatel into place, citing a June 17 order from the B.C. Environmental Assessment Office to resolve its worker-housing plans.
香蕉视频直播淲oodfibre LNG is committed to avoiding impacts and maximizing local benefits for the community,香蕉视频直播� the company香蕉视频直播檚 website states, noting that non-local workers won香蕉视频直播檛 be allowed into nearby communities, but transported to 香蕉视频直播淰ancouver.香蕉视频直播�
香蕉视频直播淭he floatel was specifically selected to promote a safe and culturally inclusive work environment 香蕉视频直播� All workers on the floatel undergo mandatory, in-person cultural awareness and gender safety training delivered by Indigenous trainers.香蕉视频直播�
But the decision to move workers onto the ship 香蕉视频直播� and the speed at which it was deployed 香蕉视频直播� raised concerns about the social impacts of industrial work camps, which led to the recent judicial review.
Central to the case was the concern for an increased risk of violence toward Indigenous women, girls, and 2SLGBTQ+ people.
Those concerns, Brown said, point to a deeper legal question 香蕉视频直播� one that Justice Grammond appeared open to considering: whether governments have a positive obligation not only to avoid causing harm, but to actively prevent it.
This evolving legal concept, especially relevant in cases of gender-based violence, is also gaining traction in climate and human rights litigation.
To illustrate this shift, Grammond cited La Rose v. Canada, a Youth-led climate lawsuit challenging the federal government香蕉视频直播檚 responsibility to protect life and security for future generations.
香蕉视频直播淭hat香蕉视频直播檚 a win 香蕉视频直播� a huge win 香蕉视频直播� and probably a much bigger win than we would have won if we simply won the judicial review,香蕉视频直播� Brown said.
What the decision didn香蕉视频直播檛 do, however, was halt the project 香蕉视频直播� or require any changes to its existing authorizations. The court accepted the government香蕉视频直播檚 claim that there wasn香蕉视频直播檛 enough evidence on record to prove harm.
But as Brown pointed out, that wasn香蕉视频直播檛 because harm isn香蕉视频直播檛 happening.
香蕉视频直播淗e香蕉视频直播檚 just saying there香蕉视频直播檚 no evidence here on the record for me to make a determination,香蕉视频直播� said Brown, alleging an absence of monitoring programs or data transparency from Woodfibre LNG.
香蕉视频直播淚t香蕉视频直播檚 a catch-22,香蕉视频直播� Brown said. 香蕉视频直播淏ut I think what his decision did was it affirmed the law as it applied 香蕉视频直播� and that香蕉视频直播檚 super helpful.
香蕉视频直播淪o if we香蕉视频直播檙e right on the law, now we just need the evidence.香蕉视频直播�
香蕉视频直播楾his industry has divided our community香蕉视频直播�
During an interview with IndigiNews, Tiaoutenaat wore a shirt featuring an Indigenous design of a sloth hanging from a tree. It featured the words 香蕉视频直播淪loth Life香蕉视频直播� 香蕉视频直播� which is ironic, since Tiaoutenaat is anything but slow.
She香蕉视频直播檚 deeply involved in S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh education, the shaping of the nation香蕉视频直播檚 child welfare laws, and 香蕉视频直播� though she香蕉视频直播檇 rather not have to be 香蕉视频直播� opposing the Eagle Mountain-Woodfibre gas pipeline project. She tries to fit all of this in amongst caring, and being present for her family, which often means juggling a whole load of priorities.
香蕉视频直播淚 think some people see me as an Elder, but I香蕉视频直播檓 going to keep staying busy doing what I do for as long as I can,香蕉视频直播� she said.
Tiaoutenaat expressed the stress she was feeling about an upcoming Woodfibre meeting later that afternoon, which overlapped with her family circle.
She and her husband planned to tag team the meeting so she could spend time with their kids and grandkids.
香蕉视频直播淭hey mean everything to me,香蕉视频直播� she said.
Tiaoutenaat worries about their safety, as well as her own. She sees FortisBC workers in town 香蕉视频直播� who are working on pipeline construction, and living among the S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh community 香蕉视频直播� and wonders if they know who she is.
香蕉视频直播淚香蕉视频直播檝e been a loud opponent to this,香蕉视频直播� she said. 香蕉视频直播淎nd I know they香蕉视频直播檝e taken my picture.香蕉视频直播�
Tiaoutenaat isn香蕉视频直播檛 the only one. Tracey Saxby, executive director and co-founder of My Sea to Sky said she has also witnessed pipeline workers taking her picture.
香蕉视频直播淭o be fair, I香蕉视频直播檓 also taking photos of what is happening at the site,香蕉视频直播� said Saxby, 香蕉视频直播渁lthough I香蕉视频直播檓 not specifically trying to capture photos of the workers themselves.香蕉视频直播�
Tiaoutenaat said she worries they might be sharing her photo around.
香蕉视频直播淲hat if somebody meant to do me harm?香蕉视频直播� she asked.
In being a vocal opponent to the project, Tiaoutenaat says she feels 香蕉视频直播渧ery alone.香蕉视频直播�
Tiaoutenaat declined self-defence classes offered by FortisBC for S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh community members, explaining that accepting would feel too much like siding with the company.
Even members of Tiaoutenaat香蕉视频直播� own family who oppose the pipeline often don香蕉视频直播檛 speak out 香蕉视频直播� she believes because they香蕉视频直播檙e afraid of alienating friends or family employed by the project.
香蕉视频直播淭his industry has divided our community,香蕉视频直播� she said, holding back tears.
香蕉视频直播淚t香蕉视频直播檚 hard to stand up for what香蕉视频直播檚 right. I know in my heart, in my mind, what I香蕉视频直播檓 doing is right.香蕉视频直播�
The other S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh applicant in the judicial review 香蕉视频直播� the 17-year-old high school student 香蕉视频直播� told the judge she feels unsafe living alongside workers from the project.
She works part-time at a local business and worries about her safety both at work, and when spending time outdoors around Howe Sound.
Unlike the 650 workers on the floatel 香蕉视频直播� who work in two-week sprints and are barred from visiting the town 香蕉视频直播� non-local FortisBC pipeline workers and other project sub-contractors will stay in hotels and short-term rentals in town.
The National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls 香蕉视频直播� which released its final report in 2019 香蕉视频直播� documented connections between industrial projects and increased violence against Indigenous women, girls, and Two-Spirit people.
Knowledge keepers and other expert witnesses told the inquiry that 香蕉视频直播渞esource extraction projects can drive violence against Indigenous women in several ways,香蕉视频直播� the report noted, for instance because of a transient workforce, substance use, economic insecurity, rotational shift work, and workplace harassment and assault.
They argued that resource extraction projects 香蕉视频直播渃an lead to increased violence against Indigenous women at the hands of non-Indigenous men, as well as increased violence within Indigenous communities.香蕉视频直播�
Listed in the commission香蕉视频直播檚 calls for justice report are several recommendations specifically for extractive and development industries.
Those recommendations included that all projects undergo gender-based impact assessments that consider Indigenous women and girls香蕉视频直播� safety.
Woodfibre LNG says it did do such an assessment, with early input from S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh Nation.
Woodfibre website states that it set up a Gender Safety Advisory Committee in 2022 to recognize the 香蕉视频直播渃entral importance of inclusion, economic participation, and safety of Indigenous women and 2SLGBTQIA people.香蕉视频直播�
The committee 香蕉视频直播� co-chaired by Woodfibre LNG President Christine Kennedy and S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh 脷xwumixw Elder Gwen Harry 香蕉视频直播� includes Indigenous and non-Indigenous women from S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh, as well as representatives from Tsleil-Waututh Nation, local service providers, and regulatory bodies.
A seat at the table 香蕉视频直播� or a compromise?
For more than 40 years, PearlSpace has served as a frontline resource for women and gender-diverse people in Skwxw煤7mesh, Lil香蕉视频直播檞at and Stl香蕉视频直播櫭l香蕉视频直播檌mx territories, offering emergency shelter, emotional support, sexual assault response, and drop-in services for as many as 60 people a day.
But in recent years, the organization has also taken on a more complicated role 香蕉视频直播� as a participant on Woodfibre LNG香蕉视频直播檚 Gender Safety Advisory Committee, and a recipient of donations from the company.
Ashley Oakes, PearlSpace香蕉视频直播檚 executive director, said she didn香蕉视频直播檛 enter that relationship lightly.
香蕉视频直播淚 felt like it was my responsibility to be there,香蕉视频直播� she told IndigiNews, describing the company香蕉视频直播檚 years of engagement as challenging. In those days, she recalled, advocates felt they had to push the company to even acknowledge gender-based violence was a risk related to their project.
香蕉视频直播淭he focus was on broad community safety,香蕉视频直播� Oakes said, 香蕉视频直播渨hich is just not really narrowing in enough on the real worries of the populations we serve, Skwxw煤7mesh Nation, and the impacts on Indigenous women and girls.香蕉视频直播�
Oakes hopes her presence at the table allows her to push directly for more safety measures through a lens of gender-based violence 香蕉视频直播� both in Skwxw煤7mesh, and on board the floating work camp itself.
香蕉视频直播淚f no one香蕉视频直播檚 at the table from this side of things,香蕉视频直播� she said, 香蕉视频直播渢hen I worry that accountability won香蕉视频直播檛 necessarily be the same.香蕉视频直播�
Oakes said she supports efforts from Woodfibre香蕉视频直播檚 to recruit more women onto the site 香蕉视频直播� currently about one-third of workers on board are women 香蕉视频直播� but she noted that culture doesn香蕉视频直播檛 change automatically with representation.
香蕉视频直播淭hat香蕉视频直播檚 where code of conduct enforcement really comes into play,香蕉视频直播� she said.
PearlSpace, which started receiving community grants from Woodfibre LNG and FortisBC 香蕉视频直播渨ell before香蕉视频直播� Oakes joined the Gender Safety Advisory Committee, she said, emphasized her role is unpaid.
香蕉视频直播淚 did say, and they agreed, that at no point would I be softening my approach with the companies,香蕉视频直播� she added, 香蕉视频直播渆ven if they were giving us money.香蕉视频直播�
But Brown questioned the effectiveness of a company-led committee. 香蕉视频直播淚 don香蕉视频直播檛 feel comfortable candidly talking about women香蕉视频直播檚 safety in a room full of Woodfibre people,香蕉视频直播� she said.
Since the floatel started taking on workers, Oakes香蕉视频直播檚 focus has broadened 香蕉视频直播� to include their well-being as well.
Because non-local workers can香蕉视频直播檛 come into town, many of them are cut off and isolated.
She raised questions about how the company is handling workplace mental health, safety, and the enforcement of its code of conduct 香蕉视频直播� especially when it comes to Indigenous women and gender-diverse people on staff.
She香蕉视频直播檚 visited the floatel once, before it docked. And after she pointed out several safety suggestions, those were since implemented, she said.
Asked about how many reports of bullying, harassment or violence the committee has received, Oakes replied by email that the committee does receive regular reports 香蕉视频直播� but referred further questions to Woodfibre LNG, citing confidentiality.
She added that, to her knowledge, no one accessing PearlSpace香蕉视频直播檚 services has yet disclosed a violent event related to the project.
In an email, Woodfibre told IndigiNews there have been two incidents of harassment and bullying reported on the floatel.
香蕉视频直播淚n both cases,香蕉视频直播� the company spokesperson wrote, 香蕉视频直播渢he individuals involved were employees of project contractors and were immediately removed from site and have been permanently banned from working on the project.香蕉视频直播�
Woodfibre LNG stated that more than 4,800 people have completed 香蕉视频直播済ender and cultural safety programs香蕉视频直播� as part of their mandatory site orientation.
香蕉视频直播淭his training is a foundational element of our approach,香蕉视频直播� the company said, 香蕉视频直播渄esigned to ensure every person on site understands our shared values and behavioral expectations.香蕉视频直播�
Brown believes that the low figure of harassment and violence documented so far could be due to under-reporting, because women are often afraid to complain about bullying or harassment, for fear of repercussions.
When complaints aren香蕉视频直播檛 surfacing, said Brown, that may not mean there香蕉视频直播檚 nothing to report.
Instead, it could equally mean the reporting systems themselves aren香蕉视频直播檛 working.
香蕉视频直播淎nd if the public doesn香蕉视频直播檛 have access to reports or data, there香蕉视频直播檚 no accountability,香蕉视频直播� she said.
For Brown, violence against women is a clear human rights issue 香蕉视频直播� one that governments and regulators must take responsibility for addressing. 香蕉视频直播淲ithout accountability, those responsibilities are effectively meaningless,香蕉视频直播� Brown argued. 香蕉视频直播淭hey香蕉视频直播檙e not accountable to the community, to Skwxw煤7mesh Nation, or to the government 香蕉视频直播� they香蕉视频直播檙e accountable to their shareholders.香蕉视频直播�
Plans for a second floatel
On May 1, Woodfibre announced it is seeking to place a second floatel at the worksite, accommodating 900 more tradespeople.
Its proposal is currently under consideration by the District of Squamish for a temporary use permit, which is scheduled to be heard by municipal councillors on July 29.
And the province opened public consultations on the proposal earlier this month, with public comment allowed until Aug. 2.
香蕉视频直播淚 just feel helpless.香蕉视频直播� Tiaoutenaat sat, casting a troubled glance towards the Woodfibre plant, just across the water.
香蕉视频直播淭hey disregard human life, disregard the environment.香蕉视频直播�
Woodfibre hopes that adding a second floatel will accelerate construction.
香蕉视频直播淚f we can have more workers on site, working parallel on different levels of construction, we香蕉视频直播檙e going to be able to finish the project as quickly as we can,香蕉视频直播� said Woodfibre spokesperson Sean Beardow at a July 2 public hearing.
As the District of Squamish prepares to make its decision, Tiaoutenaat and the group My Sea to Sky are raising concerns about the proposed location of a second floatel 香蕉视频直播� directly below a dam 香蕉视频直播� and what they allege are safety risks to workers housed there.
In a letter obtained by IndigiNews, Graham Parkinson 香蕉视频直播� a senior geoscientist at Klohn Crippen Berger engineering consulting firm 香蕉视频直播� warned of the danger posed by a potential dam breach.
The Henriette Lake Dam, owned by Woodfibre LNG, sits above the proposed floatel site, in a valley that channels water directly to where the vessel would be moored.
Parkinson has responded to two dam-breach studies prepared by Northwest Hydraulic Consultants (NHC), a firm previously hired by Woodfibre LNG.
However, only a one-page summary has been made public.
According to Parkinson, the summary 香蕉视频直播渁ppears to underestimate the potential for ocean wave generation by a dam breach flood.香蕉视频直播� He said there are likely several reasons for this 香蕉视频直播渢hat could be confirmed if the full report was made available.香蕉视频直播�
He also characterized the NHC summaries as 香蕉视频直播渙verly dismissive of potential ocean wave amplitudes, given the large amount of energy that will be deposited during a dam breach/debris flow event.香蕉视频直播�
Such a failure of the dam could, for instance, be triggered by an earthquake.
According to an Oct. 12, 2023 letter released by My Sea to Sky, the province香蕉视频直播檚 Dam Safety Section wrote that Woodfibre LNG reevaluated the chances of the dam failing 香蕉视频直播� with the likelihood deemed 香蕉视频直播渕oderate,香蕉视频直播� but the consequence 香蕉视频直播渆xtreme.香蕉视频直播�
Yet Woodfibre香蕉视频直播檚 summary of the NHC studies still state that 香蕉视频直播渁 breach of Henriette Dam would not result in any significant wave activity within Howe Sound.香蕉视频直播�
In Saxby香蕉视频直播檚 view, the company香蕉视频直播檚 response doesn香蕉视频直播檛 reflect the severity of the risk.
香蕉视频直播淲hile Woodfibre LNG has now been operating without a [municipal] permit for over a year with a clear disregard for the safety of its workers,香蕉视频直播� wrote Saxby in an email to the District of Squamish. 香蕉视频直播渢he company is now planning to double the number of workers housed below Henriette Lake Dam from 650 to 1,300 workers.香蕉视频直播�
Saxby cited a deadly landslide in Lions Bay that killed two people earlier this year; the incident is being investigated to determine whether a dam located above the debris flow could have caused the tragedy. Neighbours of the deceased sued the owner of that dam.
As Tiaoutenaat sees it, the land and waters underneath the floatel, the LNG plant, and the gas pipeline belong first to the wildlife that have depended on them since time immemorial 香蕉视频直播� despite decades of polluting industries.
香蕉视频直播淎ll the sea lions, the herring, the whales,香蕉视频直播� said Tiaoutenaat, 香蕉视频直播渢hey香蕉视频直播檙e only just starting to come back.香蕉视频直播�
Tiaoutenaat wonders what S岣祑x瘫w煤7mesh will be like in 10 years. Fears about climate change 香蕉视频直播� and how another fossil fuel project could accelerate it 香蕉视频直播� weighs heavily on her.
香蕉视频直播淚香蕉视频直播檓 angry because I feel like we香蕉视频直播檙e contributing to that,香蕉视频直播� she said. 香蕉视频直播淚 feel responsible, and I shouldn香蕉视频直播檛 have to carry that.香蕉视频直播�
But she says one thing she won香蕉视频直播檛 do is give up.
